Bill Vance/William Cole (photo via Manson Blog) making the acquaintance of George Spahn before Lynette Fromme did isn't exactly topical to the MB faithful. In her informative article from May, 2020, Deb showed us two California driver's licenses for Vance/Cole. One was issued Nov. 2, 1965, and the other on September 8, 1969. Both show Spahn Movie Ranch as Bill's address.
https://www.mansonblog.com/search/label/Bill%20Vance.
If you're new to the study and haven't seen that article, make sure you read through the comments at the end. Manson Blog readers do a good job of aggregating the commonly cited sources and their opinions on who first found Spahn and Gresham.
There's always so much love here.
We also learn from Deb's article that Vance/Cole added a third driver's license using the name Dwayne Ernest Schwarm just eleven days after becoming William Cole on September 8, 1969. Dude was preparing to run.
But let's go back to Fromme's Reflexion for a moment. Vance told her he hadn't "seen George in years" (255). That's an odd way to phrase things when your current driver's license identifies Spahn's as your home address but whatever. Two and a half years is years I suppose.
It's interesting that Fromme lets us know he's a bullshitter without saying it in the paragraph she introduces him to us. Throughout the book, she never calls him anything other than Cowboy Bill. Not a single surname.
And did you notice who told Bill about Charlie and company staying at the ranch, according to Fromme? Ruby Pearl (255).
Most important here is that Deb's information verifies the author's. Which is an amazing thing in the world of Manson.
Vance also tells Fromme that he did time with Charlie "down south" (255). Charlie saying that Vance was heavyweight boxing champ at Brushy Mountain State Prison in Tennessee nine years in a row immediately popped into my mind, probably yours as well, but as Deb pointed out, Charlie was never in prison in Tennessee.
He was, however, incarcerated in Virginia. Petersburg, to be exact. Twenty-five miles southeast of the state capitol in Richmond.
What was Charlie thinking? Just three months past his seventeenth birthday and so close to free. His aunt was trying to spring him and the Man was considering it. But Charlie being Charlie fixed all that for himself, sadly.
One short month before a parole hearing that might've freed him from a minimum security honor camp, Charlie was caught raping a boy at knifepoint.
I'll spare you the condemnation I feel for a society that puts little boys in cages with bigger boys who have become feral dogs, and move things along to the location of Charlie's punishment and possible meeting place of Bill Vance in an attempt to keep myself from raging while I weep.
Here's a little Wiki background because we all know Wikipedia never lies.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Correctional_Complex,_Petersburg
Charlie arrives at the Federal Reformatory Petersburg, Virginia, in January, 1952.
The prison made a nice little book so families could forever memorialize the time their loved ones spent in the guiding arms of Uncle Sam.
And also just in case you owned a factory or something and had an interest in not paying your employees, several photos were included to give you an idea of some options. Like for example if you were a manufacturer of giant shoelace fences.
Finally, the clean-living and vitality of your potential slaves, apologies, employees, is proactively demonstrated.
Did Charlie and Bill Vance meet down in Dixie like Bill told Lynette Fromme? And if so, was Petersburg the place? D.C. is the only other option, and most people say, "D.C." when talking about the area. Not "down south" (255).
So yeah maybe.
Side note: Amateur and professional genealogists in the group will surely recognize the Scots-Irish, Irish, English, and Welsh mix going on there in ole Bill. I'd bet a dollar if I was a betting man that his peeps came in through Virginia, built shacks in WVA hollers, fought natives across the Ohio, and spread westward with the great hillbilly mass of which I am part.
Lurk on.
Vance's IDs were apparently issued by the California DMV. How did he manage to get them to issue him these phony IDs?
ReplyDeleteSaying you lost your license probably used to work if you didn't roll up into the DMV with crazy long hair and Clem's ripped pantalones. Seems like Bill had the same excuse every time. Computers weren't really linked yet like today, either.
ReplyDeleteSchwarm was the name that a bunch of the stolen checks police recovered were made out to. I assumed that name was adopted, and ID procured, for the purpose of cashing those checks and not to run.
ReplyDeletehttps://www.mansonblog.com/2020_03_09_archive.html
A lot of those cheques seemed to be connected to Haught/Zero too
DeleteGreenWhite said...
ReplyDelete"Computers weren't really linked yet like today"
The point is is that the DMV wouldn't have just taken your word for it. Even back then, they had ways to weed out the fraudsters, even without computers(and I think they DID use computers in that era). Yet somehow Vance was able to bypass those safeguards.
IMO bill vance (or whatever his actual name is), once he became a "Family" member or associate at the beginning of 1969, was a MAJOR influence on manson and was largely responsible for the group's transformation from a (relatively) peaceful commune into a band of weapon-hoarding, dune-buggy building band of paranoid survivalists. Furthermore, the group had no history of breaking into private homes and (occasionally at least) stealing things before vance entered the picture. If there's one individual connected to this whole story who definitely merits further research, and who has up to now mostly avoided scrutiny, it's vance.
ReplyDeleteBill was top man. Charlie wrangled the girls.
DeleteAgree with that. Vance is very interesting. Wish we knew more about him.
ReplyDeleteVance is alleged to have married Family associate Claudia Leigh Smith later on. Did anybody ever get ahold of her for an interview?
ReplyDeleteAnyone but me think ‘down south’ from California might mean Mexico.
ReplyDeleteGood point, David.
ReplyDeleteWas Charlie ever in the joint in Mexico?
ReplyDeleteCan anyone tell me the use of giant shoelace fences? I've seen them somewhere but can't remember where.
ReplyDeleteorwhut said...
ReplyDelete"Was Charlie ever in the joint in Mexico?"
Manson claimed he was in a prison/jail in Mexico City reserved for foreigners sometime in 1960(from the Emmons book). Little else is known about Charlie's Mexico trip.
Charlie in Mexico-
ReplyDeletehttps://www.mansonblog.com/2017/04/charles-manson-1959-1960.html
Star and Brownrice,
ReplyDeleteThank you both. I'd read both the book and article and had completely forgotten about Charlie's Mexico visit.
Whut
Was Vance such a bad influence? Those very interesting articles about his reverend cole post manson commune paint him as not so bad... Could be a sort of PTSD reaction to the murders made him act better. What happened to him after he fled the farm?
ReplyDeleteOrwhut - Re the shoelace fences - I was thinking those climbing nets on assault courses.
ReplyDeleteManson was busted in Nuevo Laredo (Tamaulipas), Mexico at one time. That's just across the bridge from Laredo, Texas. He was pimping women, I believe. I'm sure he was down there in other areas too. Boy, for being an unemployed bum, he seemed to always have traveling money, didn't he?
ReplyDeleteMilly,
ReplyDeleteThanks. You could be right. Something I surfed up, which didn't seem to be an exact fit, made me think they might have been used to slow down or catch some type of aircraft.
A researcher has made a pretty good case that the true name of Bill Vance was in fact William J Van Sickle, born April 17, 1933.
ReplyDeletemansonrelatedblog.blogspot.com/2021/09/real-identity-of-bill-vance-aka-william.html
I meant to link that last night, Star. Thank you. I found the 1940 census the article references and it's right on. I was unable to find a birth certificate or record of it with Bill and him mom on the same document however. But I feel like even without it, the argument looks sound. Smart way to go about it, too. What did you think of the piece?
ReplyDelete7 Nov 2021
ReplyDeleteSunday
If anyone is on West Coast time or stays up later in other time zones and wants to hang out tonight, I'm a guest host on The Paulcast tonight at 730 pm PST.
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCOxfXLe8Y8p7RVwPUaHWtCg
My discussion will center on unique perspectives, research methodologies, and cognitive dissonance in the Manson study.
GreenWhite said...
ReplyDeleteWhat did you think of the piece?
Anybody who can come up with new, original info on this case has my greatest respect. I'll be tuning in tonight! See you there.
Star - I liked it. And I've definitely done a bunch of research and thought I uncovered a giant secret only to check previous blog articles and find five discussions with large comments sections on the same subject. In fact, it's happened so many times that I now check first before I start typing.
ReplyDeleteLooking forward to hanging out with you tonight.