This is an episode of To Tell the Truth with Jay Sebring as the guest. January 28 1963!
To Tell the Truth was a game show that aired from 1956-1968. There was a panel of four celebrities whose task it was to figure out which of three contestants was telling the truth about something in particular, it could be an event, their occupation or simply something notable that the person had done. Each wrong vote the panel made earned the impostor $100 in the daytime version or $250 in the nighttime version.
Thank you Max Frost for sending this to us!